Estate dispute lawyers Melbourne

Disputes over a Will or inheritance can be stressful. Carew Counsel provides clear legal advice and representation to help you understand your rights, protect your interests and resolve estate disputes.

Carew Counsel awarded Doyle family law firm of 2021Carew Counsel awarded Doyle family law firm of 2022Carew Counsel awarded Doyle family law firm of 2023
Carew Counsel estate dispute lawyers in Melbourne advising a client.
Carew Counsel Family law firm icon

Specialist family law firm

We have 40+ years of experience dealing with family law matters.

Carew Counsel Client first icon

Client focused

Get the help, guidance, and legal support you need to move forward.

Carew Counsel Award winning icon

Commendable service

We’re ranked in the top five family law firms in Melbourne.

Open and upfront

We will clearly outline expectations and a quote for legal fees following your initial consultation.

Carew Counsel lawyers discussing an estate dispute with a client.

Legal support for Will and estate disputes

Estate disputes can be emotionally difficult, particularly when family relationships and inheritance are involved. At Carew Counsel, we help clients navigate complex estate matters with clear advice, personalised support and practical guidance.

Whether you're facing a disagreement over a Will or managing a claim against an estate, our lawyers can assist with:

  • Family provision claims involving inadequate inheritance
  • Disputes over a Will's validity or testamentary capacity
  • Estate litigation and disagreements between beneficiaries
Protecting your interests

Is an estate dispute service right for me?

Estate disputes can arise when disagreements occur over a Will, inheritance or the distribution of assets. If you're facing an estate dispute in Victoria, our lawyers can help you understand your legal position and explore the options available.

Our estate dispute service can help if you need to:

  • Contest a Will because you believe you've been unfairly excluded.
  • Make a family provision claim against a deceased estate.
  • Challenge a Will you believe is legally invalid.
  • Raise concerns about the Willmaker's testamentary capacity.
  • Address suspected undue influence when a Will was prepared.
  • Defend an estate against a claim made by another party.
  • Resolve disagreements over inherited property or assets.
  • Address concerns about an executor's legal obligations.
  • Explore negotiation, mediation or court proceedings.
Understanding Will disputes

When you believe a Will may be invalid

Client situation: A client approached Carew Counsel after discovering they had been excluded from their late parents' Will. Concerned about their financial future, they wanted to understand their legal rights and whether they could claim a share of the estate.

What this could mean

In this situation, our estate dispute lawyers would assess the client's eligibility to make a family provision claim under Victorian law. We would review their circumstances and explain the available options for resolving the dispute.

  • Assess eligibility: Review the client's relationship with the deceased and financial needs.
  • Explore resolution: Consider negotiation or mediation before court proceedings.
  • Protect their interests: Explain the legal process and applicable time limits.
Estate dispute lawyer discussing an inheritance claim with a client.
Preparing for your consultation

What to prepare for an estate dispute

Before speaking with our estate dispute lawyers, gathering relevant documents and information can help us understand your situation. You don't need to have everything ready, but providing what you have can make your initial consultation more productive.

What information should I have ready?

Our legal team will need to understand your relationship with the deceased, the nature of the dispute and what you hope to achieve. Bring any relevant documents you have available, including:

  • Will and estate documents: A copy of the Will, any previous versions and probate documents, if available.
  • Financial and property information: Details of known estate assets, including real estate, bank accounts and business interests.
  • Relevant correspondence: Letters, emails or messages relating to the Will, inheritance or dispute.

What if I don't have a copy of the Will?

You can still contact us if you haven't received a copy of the Will or don't know where to locate it. Under Victorian law, certain people are entitled to inspect a deceased person's Will. Our lawyers can help you check your eligibility and explain how to request the document.

We can also discuss what other information may be necessary to assess your claim.

What should I know about estate dispute time limits?

Estate disputes can involve strict legal deadlines. In Victoria, family provision claims generally must be commenced within six months of the grant of probate or letters of administration. Other types of estate disputes may have different requirements.

  • Seek advice early: Don't wait until estate assets have been distributed.

What questions should I prepare for my lawyer?

Before your appointment, consider what you want to understand or achieve from the estate dispute. Preparing a few questions can help our legal team provide advice that addresses your concerns.

  • Your legal rights: Am I eligible to contest the Will or make a claim?
  • Potential outcomes: What factors could affect my claim and the resolution I can achieve?
  • Costs and risks: What legal fees, time limits or financial risks should I consider?
Close-up office wall sign displaying the text Carew Counsel Solicitors.

Why choose Carew Counsel for estate disputes?

Icon of the scales of justice, representing legal expertise

Experienced estate dispute lawyers

Our legal team provides clear advice on Victorian estate law, helping you navigate Will disputes, inheritance claims and litigation with confidence.

Icon of a hand holding a heart, representing compassionate legal guidance

Compassionate guidance during difficult times

We recognise the emotional impact of estate disputes and approach every matter with sensitivity, respect and professionalism.

Icon of a person speaking, representing clear advice in plain English

Clear communication and support

We explain your options in plain language, keep you informed and provide reliable support throughout your estate dispute.

Icon of a handshake, representing practical dispute resolution

A practical approach to dispute resolution

We prioritise negotiation and mediation where appropriate, helping you pursue a resolution without unnecessary legal costs.

How we work with you

Our estate dispute resolution process

1

Initial consultation and case assessment

We discuss your concerns, review your circumstances and assess your legal position. Our lawyers explain your rights, available options and potential costs.

2

Reviewing evidence and estate documents

Our legal team examines the Will, probate records, financial information and relevant evidence to identify potential grounds for your claim or defence.

3

Developing your legal strategy

We recommend an approach based on your circumstances, the strength of your position and your desired outcome, while considering costs and legal risks.

4

Negotiation and mediation

Where appropriate, we engage with the other parties to explore settlement options through negotiation or mediation, aiming to avoid unnecessary court proceedings.

5

Court representation and resolution

If an agreement cannot be reached, we can represent your interests in estate litigation and guide you through the court process towards a resolution.

Black-and-white group photo of the Carew Counsel Solicitors team, a diverse group of professionals in business attire standing side by side and facing forward against a plain background.
Transparent legal costs

How much does an estate dispute service cost?

The cost of resolving an estate dispute depends on the complexity of your matter, the work required and whether court proceedings are necessary. Carew Counsel provides a personalised cost estimate following an initial consultation.

Initial legal consultation

Charged at the solicitor's hourly rate

Your initial consultation lasts up to 90 minutes and is charged at your solicitor’s hourly rate. During this appointment, we discuss your circumstances, review the legal issues involved and explain your available options.

Includes:

  • Discussion of your estate dispute
  • Initial review of relevant information
  • Advice on your available legal options

Estate dispute legal representation

Customised costs estimate

Our lawyers provide a tailored estimate based on the nature of your claim, the complexity of the dispute and the legal work required.

Includes, where relevant:

  • Reviewing estate documents and evidence
  • Negotiating with other parties
  • Preparing for mediation or litigation

Court proceedings and estate litigation

Costs vary depending on your matter

If your estate dispute proceeds to court, legal costs will depend on the proceedings, the evidence required, and the time involved. Our team will discuss the anticipated costs and relevant risks with you.

Professional image of Peter Carew, Director, Accredited Family Law Specialist, Wills and Estate Planning at Carew Counsel.
Advice from our legal team

A lawyer's perspective on estate disputes

“Disagreements about an estate can place considerable strain on families during an already difficult time. Seeking legal advice early helps you understand your rights and responsibilities, address concerns about the Will or its administration and work towards a resolution.”

Peter Carew
Director, Accredited Family Law Specialist, Wills and Estate Planning
Making a difference

Decades of legal experience supporting Victorian families

Carew Counsel combines estate planning services with extensive family law expertise. Our lawyers understand how family relationships and future circumstances can affect your estate plan.

45

Years practising family and estate law

Top 5

Recognised among Melbourne's top five family law firms in Doyle's Guide.

4x

Law Australasia Pursuit of Excellence Awards winners.

4

Accredited Family Law Specialists

Book a free 15-minute callback

Get started by discussing your situation with a family law expert.

Carew Counsel Solicitors staff working at front desk
Experience you can rely on

Meet our estate dispute law team in Melbourne

success stories

What our clients say about Carew Counsel

Estate disputes can be emotionally challenging, making trusted legal support especially important. Discover what clients have shared about their experience with Carew Counsel, from clear communication and compassionate guidance to professional legal representation.

“I'm extremely thankful and appreciative to Keleigh, Naomi and Kimberly of Carew Counsel for the efficiency and stress free handling of all matters relating to Estate and Probate closure. A quite complicated matter I was relieved of having to worry about any of the finalisation. Thank you”

Barbara R.

“I had the pleasure of working with Bronwyn Gunning at Carew Counsel during a challenging time. From the outset, she took the time to explain every step of the process clearly, provided practical advice, and guided me through each stage with professionalism and care. Bronwyn was supportive, responsive, and helped resolve the matter efficiently, giving me confidence throughout the process. Her expertise and genuine commitment made what could have been a very stressful experience much easier to navigate. I highly recommend Bronwyn Gunning and the team at Carew Counsel to anyone looking for knowledgeable, compassionate, and professional legal assistance.”

Adrian M.

Our awards and memberships

AMDRAS Accredited Mediator logo.
Beyond the practice

Features and professional contributions

Explore Carew Counsel's contributions to legal education and appearances in Australian media, reflecting our team's professional involvement.

Podcast

Greek Artefacts, Discovery & Disclosure

Keleigh Robinson joined Foley's List's Daze in Court podcast to discuss disclosure obligations in family law.
Editorial contribution

The Family Law Book

Keleigh Robinson is co-editor of the Family Law Book.
Industry event

Peter Carew at a FLAV industry event

Peter Carew participated in a Family Law Association Victoria event covered by Foley's List in September 2025.

Frequently asked questions about estate disputes

We explain how estate disputes work in Victoria, who may be eligible to make a claim and what to consider before taking legal action.

What are the most common types of estate disputes?

Estate disputes often involve disagreements about the validity of a Will, how assets are distributed or whether adequate provision has been made for an eligible family member.

Common disputes include:

  • Family provision claims: Seeking further provision from a deceased person's estate.
  • Will validity disputes: Challenging a Will due to concerns about testamentary capacity, undue influence or improper execution.
  • Executor disputes: Concerns about how an executor is administering an estate or fulfilling their legal obligations.
  • Beneficiary disputes: Disagreements about inheritance entitlements or the interpretation of a Will.

An estate dispute lawyer can assess your circumstances and explain which legal options may apply.

Who can contest a Will in Victoria?

Under the Administration and Probate Act 1958 (VIC), certain eligible people can apply to the Supreme Court of Victoria for further provision from a deceased person's estate.

Eligible applicants may include a spouse or domestic partner, children, certain dependents, and other people who meet the Act's requirements.

Eligibility does not automatically mean a claim will succeed. The Court considers factors such as your relationship with the deceased, financial circumstances and whether the deceased had a moral duty to provide for you.

How long do I have to contest a Will in Victoria?

Family provision claims in Victoria generally must be commenced within six months of the grant of probate or letters of administration.

The Supreme Court may allow an application outside this period in certain circumstances, subject to statutory restrictions.

Other types of estate disputes may have different legal requirements and time limits. It is important to seek legal advice promptly rather than assume the same deadline applies to every claim.

Can I challenge a Will if I believe it is invalid?

Yes. A Will may be challenged where there are legitimate concerns about its legal validity.

Potential grounds include:

  • The deceased lacked testamentary capacity when making the Will.
  • The Will was created through undue influence.
  • The document does not comply with relevant legal requirements.
  • There are concerns about fraud or forgery.

A strong challenge generally requires supporting evidence, such as medical records, witness statements or other relevant documents.

Our lawyers can review the circumstances and explain whether there may be grounds to challenge the Will.

Can an estate dispute be resolved without going to court?

Yes. Many estate disputes can be resolved through negotiation or mediation without requiring a final court hearing.

These approaches allow parties to discuss their concerns, consider settlement options and potentially reduce the time, expense and emotional strain associated with litigation.

However, the best approach depends on the nature of the dispute, the available evidence and the willingness of the parties to negotiate.

Where court proceedings are necessary, Carew Counsel can provide legal representation and guide you through the process.

What happens if an estate includes a house or land?

Real estate can become a significant issue in inheritance disputes, particularly where beneficiaries disagree about the ownership, valuation or distribution of property.

For example, disagreements may arise over whether a family home should be retained, transferred or sold.

Depending on the circumstances, resolving the dispute may involve reviewing property valuations, ownership records and the terms of the Will.

An estate dispute lawyer can explain how Victorian succession law applies to the property and what options may be available.

What evidence do I need for an estate dispute?

The evidence required depends on the nature of your claim. Relevant documents may include the deceased person's Will, financial records, medical reports, correspondence and details of your relationship with the deceased.

For family provision claims, information about your financial circumstances and any support provided by the deceased may also be relevant.

Our legal team can assess the available evidence, identify any gaps and explain what information may help support your position.

Advice from our team

Our guide to Wills and estate planning

Understanding your legal rights can make it easier to navigate a dispute over a Will or inheritance. Explore our guides covering contested Wills, estate administration and the legal responsibilities of executors in Victoria.

Our Melbourne office

Located in the heart of Melbourne’s legal and business precinct, Carew Counsel Solicitors provides discreet, professional family law support in a calm and confidential environment.

Why visit our Melbourne office?

  • Centrally located for convenient access across metropolitan Melbourne
  • Private, professional meeting spaces designed for sensitive conversations
  • Direct access to experienced family lawyers and accredited specialists

Visit us

Level 10, 313 La Trobe Street, Melbourne, VIC 3000

Phone

Call us on 03 9670 5711

Business hours

Mon – Fri, 9 am – 5:30 pm

Parking

Wilson Parking on La Trobe St

Payment options

EFT, BPAY and Credit Card payments all accepted

Our Melbourne office

03 9670 5711
Level 10, 313 La Trobe Street, Melbourne, VIC 3000
Mon – Fri, 9 am – 5:30 pm
Wilson Parking on La Trobe St
Complete the enquiry form below and a member of our team will contact you and provide you with further information.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.